Home  |  About  |  Original Articles  |  Book and Surf Shop  |  Logo Goods


San Diego law practice

June 30, 2006 -

No Boaters’ Right To View

Reviewing a court ruling blocking development of coastal property, the Second District of California’s Appellate Court held yesterday that no “boater’s right to view” exists under California law. The decision in Schneider v. California Coastal Commission returns the matter to the Commission to review using those standards set by the legislature, which did not include the boater’s right previously relied upon by the Commission in this case. Schneider first began this attempt to build a home in San Luis Obispo county in 1997.

The Appellate Court didn’t have much sympathy for the Commission, despite some sensitivity to the size of the proposed home (10,000 square feet) and the undeveloped status of the area, writing that:

The Coastal Commission has subordinated a landowner’s real property rights to the occasional boater’s “right to a view” of the coastline. If and when the California Legislature expressly codifies a boater’s “right to a view” of the coastline, the courts can and will lawfully give it credence. But the Coastal Commission is not empowered to legislate a boater’s “right to a view” of the coastline.

Justice Yegan’s opinion also clarified that “[i]n construing [the relevant law], we look to California law not the State of Maine or the U.S. Sailing Association” referring to the Commission’s claims from these non-parties that the view of the coast from occasional passing boaters required their protection.

> Posted by Chuck at 4:58 pm. No Comments

Leave a Reply


Saturday morning, December 29, 2007: Someone seems to be really enjoying this last Saturday of 2007. Taken at the Crystal Pier in Pacific Beach.

Subscribe

Interesting Sites

Beachapedia.org Beachapedia
Cal. Coastal Commission Like them or not, they are one of the biggest players around when it comes to coastal access in California.
Howling Point Your moderator’s personal site. He does have a life outside of this, as shown by the occasional gaps in posting.
Surfrider Foundation Activities and campaigns for clean water, beach access, beach preservation and protecting special places.



White Knot

Beachlaw dot Info, your California beach use and coastal access law resource has been maintained 2002-2012 by Charles E. Hartley, Esq. Please respect the copyright and read the disclaimer and privacy policy.